essay
by RYOKO SEKIGUCHI
Japanese poet and writer Ryoko Sekiguchi began publishing in 1988. She moved to France in 1997 And has been writing in French since 2003.
Presented here in an excerpt, her journal Ce N’est Pas Un Hasard (Éditions P.O.L., Paris, 2011) was written in the days following the March 11, 2011, tsunami and nuclear disaster, reflecting on themes such as the ephemeral nature of life in Japanese culture.
In her most recent book, L’Appel des Odeurs (The Call of Odors, 2024), the narrator keeps a notebook documenting how smell influences our relations with space and memory.
March 13
The Japanese poet Tatsuhiko Ishii arrives in Paris. Exhausted.
He’s come to give a few talks and participate in a roundtable discussion on March 15, where I’ll also be present. His flight was confirmed, but since the airport shuttle seemed out of service, we thought until the last minute that he wouldn’t make it.
Ishii teaches me the etymology of the word “disaster,” from the Italian disastro, meaning “under a bad star.”
A French newspaper article wonders how the Japanese can continue living on an island so prone to natural disasters. And I wonder if the journalist would dare say something similar about the inhabitants of regions with challenging climates, such as some African countries or Iran, where earthquakes are also common.
March 14
Cécile Sakai, a specialist in Japanese literature, and I had prepared a translation of a series of Ishii’s tanka in anticipation of his reading. The selection was made in January, and the translation was completed on March 2.
On March 12, Cécile Sakai messages me, surprised: “I keep thinking about what Mr. Ishii wrote…” I had been thinking the same. He has a triptych on disasters entitled “Announcement to Humanity.” The first section opens with “The day the sea foams and the earth shakes,” followed by a quote from Voltaire on the Lisbon earthquake.
Ishii is concerned about tomorrow. He doesn’t want people to think he chose this text on purpose.
The press speaks of Japanese discipline. Some try to find an explanation in the Japanese concept of “impermanence,” others in our religion. Still others call it resignation. It’s true, I wouldn’t want to experience an earthquake in France. It would be total chaos, although maybe the government would respond faster than ours. In any case, if there is a difference, it’s not a difference in mentality. Rather, it’s a learned habit, a very pragmatic lesson that all Japanese people have internalized. After all, we know natural disasters happen. It’s not fatalism; it’s a proven fact. We know this well because we’re taught about it in school. We are trained to respond to earthquakes. Every Japanese child knows what to do in a tsunami or an avalanche in mountainous areas. But preparation can’t prevent everything. Every year, there are typhoons, sometimes causing power outages and blowing rooftops or antennas away. That’s just how it is.
True, there isn’t a major earthquake every day, but minor tremors are felt at least once a month. The pedestrian map of Tokyo is a bestseller because it helps people navigate the city if needed, to return home on foot. Every home is equipped with a large flashlight and a radio in the entryway. This is part of our daily life, and no one is spared. That’s why we have the sense that “what was bound to happen has happened,” that “it could have been me,” that one day, “it will be my turn.” Hence the feeling, not of resignation but of always being involved. This, too, perhaps explains the solidarity that prevails with every disaster. Because we know that life will resume, even if we have to start from scratch, and that it’s not the end of everything. Except, of course, for those whose lives have been abruptly cut short.
March 15
Tatsuhiko Ishii gives his reading. Here’s an excerpt:
“How simple it is to decimate men! All it takes is for the Earth to move (just a little bit).
To live humbly and die like a worm — barely enough time to utter a little cry
But you know yourself! It’s humans who are to be most feared (oh yes!)
Has humanity (already) perished? The sea foams. The earth shakes. For a moment…”
Why does such chance occur? And anyway, is it really chance? I don’t mean that poets can predict catastrophes — quite the opposite. There’s no cause-and-effect link. Only that catastrophes, innumerable, natural or human-made, arise in the world, and in this sense, if we’re not coming out of a disaster, then we’re on the verge of another.
As for writers and artists who grapple with this theme, it’s not surprising that their work, their thoughts, might immediately precede or coincide with a catastrophe.
The crucial point when we ask, “What’s possible after a catastrophe?” — a question often raised worldwide — is to bear in mind that we’re also on the eve of future catastrophes, so we should ask what we can write before or between catastrophes, the permanent state we live in.
Ishii says he couldn’t write a tanka about an earthquake. This makes me understand something: maybe one can write about catastrophes — but only afterward.
Perhaps one can write a poem afterward, but not during. I would be incapable of writing a poem during.
I understand him, too; what I’m writing isn’t literature.
It’s a “report.” I’m drafting a report, as honestly as possible.
March 17
I could never have imagined writing about “our” catastrophe.
I also think of the unique temporality that belongs to narratives of disaster, as a literary convention, that golden rule that dictates they always be described retrospectively.
One cannot arrive the day before.
Yet, when multiple catastrophes overlap as they do today, we find ourselves simultaneously before, after, and even during the disaster. Especially because, as the philosopher Osamu Nishitani says, a nuclear accident, once it occurs, is only the beginning — the beginning of a desolation that itself spawns catastrophe.
So now, in what grammatical tense should one describe this succession of catastrophes? And in what tense should one complete the description? To this difficult question, I still have no answer. By opting for the form of a chronicle, I submit myself to a specific time frame, perhaps valid only in this particular case: the present. There is also the prevailing feeling that we are always “within” the catastrophe, even if it mingles, as I have already written, with retrospective visions and projected anxieties about a future that may or may not come to pass.
For a writer aiming to narrate a catastrophe, what temporality should they choose? And before even arriving at a narration or description, in what tense does one experience the moment?
All discourse on catastrophe is inevitably bound to, even haunted by, the question of time. Since discovering this, the incessant link between time and disaster appears to me in nearly all writings on catastrophes, regardless of the genre.
END
[Table of contents]
editor’s letter
Read the article
empire of signs
by Roland Barthes
cover #1 takashi murakami
interview by Jérôme Sans
takashi murakami
interview by Jérôme Sans
ryoko sekiguchi
interview by Mark Alizart and Olivier Zahm
cover #2 motoko ishibashi
Subscription
motoko ishibashi
interview by Aleph Molinari
atsuko tanaka
Subscription
sexual assault breaking the silence
by Karyn Nishimura-Poupée
juergen teller and nobuyoshi araki
Subscriptionchiho aoshima
Subscriptionhajime sawatari
Subscription
suwa nagano
by Stéphane Sednaoui
fetish magazines
by Katerina Jebb
tadanoori yokoo
text by André Michel
kazumi asamura hayashi
Subscriptionkeiichi tanaami
Subscription
fumihiro hayashi
text by Olivier Zahm
nobuyoshi araki
portrait by Chikashi Suzuki
tomoo gokita
interview by Olivier Zahm
cover #4 tomoo gokita
Subscription
loewe s/s 2025
photography by Suffo Moncloa
hajime sorayama
Subscription
my father
by Rick Owens
announcement to humanity
by Ryoko Sekiguchi
cover #3 katerina jebb
Subscription
cover #5 loewe s/s 2025
photography by Suffo Moncloa
masahisa fukase
Read the article
hajime kinoko
interview by Olivier Zahm
raiki yamamoto
Subscriptioncover #6 masahisa fukase
Subscription
kunichi nomura
text by Aaron Rose
aya takano
Subscriptiontomoyo kawari
Subscription
masaru hatanaka
interview by Aleph Molinari
why japan?
by Urs Fischer, Ramdane Touhami, Stéphane Sednaoui
cover #8 esther rose-mcgregor in valentino s/s 2025
photography by Hart Lëshkina
why japan?
by Helmut Lang
minoru nomata
Subscription
in praise of shadows
by Jun'ichirō Tanizaki
best of the season s/s 2025
photography by Takashi Homma
purple beauty nails
by Mei Kawajiri
ryūichi sakamoto
Subscription
valentino s/s 2025
photography by Hart Lëshkina
nobuyoshi araki
Subscription
cover #10 bottega veneta
photography by Nikolai von Bismarck
balenciaga s/s 2025
photography by Juergen Teller
kazuo ohno
Subscription
cover #7 prada s/s 2025
photography by Takashi Homma
butoh the dance of darkness
photography by Nikolai von Bismarck
cover #9 balenciaga s/s 2025
photography by Juergen Teller
tomihiro kono
photography by Joe Lai
cover #12 comme des garçons s/s 2025
photography by Ola Rindal
comme des garçons s/s 2025
photography by Ola Rindal
cover #11 nobuyoshi araki
Subscription
chanel s/s 2025
photography by Chikashi Suzuki
the japanese lessons we refuse to learn
by Daido Moriyama
dualité by brioni and lalique
photography by Olivier Zahm
pink eiga
Subscription
cover #18 sakura andō in chanel s/s 2025
photography by Chikashi Suzuki
noritoshi hirakawa
Subscription
tomo koizumi
photography by Chikashi Suzuki
trails
by Takashi Homma
koji kimura
by André Michel
cover #13 dualité by brioni and lalique
photography by Olivier Zahm
daido moriyama
Subscription
erotica
by Olivier Zahm
purple story
Read the articletakuro kuwata
Subscription
cover #16 saint laurent by anthony vaccarello s/s 2025
photography by Takashi Homma
setsuko klossowska de rola
Subscription
cover #15 paul & joe
photography by Olivier Zahm
why japan?
by Coco Capitán
alejandro garcia contreras
Subscription
casablanca s/s 2025
photography by Keizo Motoda
why japan?
by Stefano Pilati
saint laurent by anthony vaccarello s/s 2025
photography by Takashi Homma
why japan?
by André
best of men s/s 2025
Photography by Kejichi Nitta
kei ninomiya
interview by Olivier Zahm
anders edström
Subscription
zen gardens
by Takashi Homma
wabi-sabi spiritual values
by Leonard Koren
wim wenders
interview by Olivier Zahm and Aleph Molinari
miu miu s/s 2025
photography by Coco Capitán
ruth asawa
Subscriptionkazuyo sejima
Subscription
waves
by Takashi Homma
jun takahashi
interview by Aleph Molinari
cover #14 casablanca s/s 2025
photography by Keizo Motoda
kumiko
by Anna Dubosc
yōko yamanaka
interview by Olivier Zahm
mariko mori
Subscription
cover #17 miu miu s/s 2025
photography by Coco Capitán
the tokyo toilet
by Koji Yanai
ann lee in anzen zone
by Dominique Gonzalez-Foerster
young designers s/s 2025
Photography by Dasom Han
kenshu shintsubo
Subscription
why japan?
by Setsuko
the original hotel okura
by Valerie Sadoun
kyoto international conference center
by Sachio Otani
tadashi kawamata
interview by Aleph Molinari
purple beauty make-up
photography by Eamonn Zeel Freel
self-portrait
Takashi Homma
kids
by Takashi Homma
hideaki kawashima
Subscriptionyoshitomo nara
Subscriptionyasujirō ozu
Subscriptionthe isamu noguchi garden museum
Subscription
yoko and john in karuizawa
by François Simon
by Roland Barthes
interview by Jérôme Sans
interview by Jérôme Sans
interview by Mark Alizart and Olivier Zahm
interview by Aleph Molinari
by Karyn Nishimura-Poupée
by Katerina Jebb
text by André Michel
text by Olivier Zahm
interview by Olivier Zahm
photography by Suffo Moncloa
photography by Suffo Moncloa
by Rick Owens
by Ryoko Sekiguchi
by Stéphane Sednaoui
interview by Olivier Zahm
portrait by Chikashi Suzuki
text by Aaron Rose
interview by Aleph Molinari
by Urs Fischer, Ramdane Touhami, Stéphane Sednaoui
by Helmut Lang
photography by Takashi Homma
photography by Takashi Homma
by Mei Kawajiri
photography by Hart Lëshkina
photography by Hart Lëshkina
photography by Joe Lai
photography by Juergen Teller
photography by Juergen Teller
photography by Nikolai von Bismarck
photography by Nikolai von Bismarck
photography by Ola Rindal
photography by Ola Rindal
by Jun'ichirō Tanizaki
photography by Olivier Zahm
photography by Olivier Zahm
photography by Keizo Motoda
photography by Keizo Motoda
photography by Chikashi Suzuki
by Takashi Homma
by André Michel
by Daido Moriyama
by Olivier Zahm
by Stefano Pilati
by Coco Capitán
photography by Olivier Zahm
photography by Takashi Homma
photography by Takashi Homma
by André
Photography by Kejichi Nitta
interview by Olivier Zahm
by Takashi Homma
by Leonard Koren
photography by Coco Capitán
photography by Coco Capitán
by Takashi Homma
interview by Aleph Molinari
interview by Olivier Zahm
by Anna Dubosc
photography by Chikashi Suzuki
photography by Chikashi Suzuki
interview by Olivier Zahm and Aleph Molinari
by Koji Yanai
by Dominique Gonzalez-Foerster
Photography by Dasom Han
by Setsuko
by Valerie Sadoun
by Sachio Otani
interview by Aleph Molinari
photography by Eamonn Zeel Freel
Takashi Homma
by Takashi Homma
by François Simon